As someone who watches a lot of movies with questionable quality, I can tell you that there are highs and lows. No two highs are the same. No two lows are the same. But the mixture of them builds an entire landscape. The peaks and the valleys. Those bad movies that are enjoyable, and the others that feel like a chore to get through.
Over time, I’ve categorized movies into four different zones. There are the good-good movies. These movies look and feel professionally made, even if they were low budget and independent. Essentially, they are well done technically and emotionally. The bad-good movies were well done technically, but fumbled the stuff that would make a movie enjoyable. Good-bad were the opposite, where the technical side wasn’t particularly well done, yet the entertainment was up there. I don’t necessarily believe in so bad it’s good, but this would be the closest to that. Or something that’s poorly made and filled with heart could fit here. Then there are the bad-bad movies that were poorly done all around. The deepest valleys.
My goal in this post is to figure out where Teen Witch fits into this landscape. Is it a peak or a valley? Louise (Robyn Lively) was a fifteen-year-old girl who was basically an outcast at school. She skipped a grade and wasn’t seen as a peer by her classmates. When she turned sixteen, she discovered she had magic powers. Louise used this magic to gain popularity and love, before tossing the powers aside because Brad (Dan Gauthier) should love her for her, not because of a spell.
On the surface, Teen Witch was your basic coming-of-age story. With magic. It was reminiscent of a girl’s version of Teen Wolf. That makes sense. From what I found, it was originally intended to be a spin-off of the 1980s Teen Wolf before becoming its own thing. The structure of the story didn’t scream anything but decent.
The production value backed that up. The lighting was good, particularly in the dance dream sequence that opened the movie. The locations and sets were all good quality with solid set dressing and design. The costuming and hairstyling and makeup were all good. The foundation was laid for a solid little movie. Maybe it was a little underbudgeted, which showed through the cast, but otherwise, it seemed like everything was there for something solid. And you kind of got it, but quality is a funny thing.
You see, my mind and heart tell me that Teen Witch should go firmly into the Good-Bad category. Based on my definition, that means that the technical stuff was bad. I just told you there weren’t any major flaws with Teen Witch. But did I? I said that it looked fine. I said it had a good framework with the coming-of-age story. What didn’t I say? What did I leave out that kept everything from coming together? You’ll have to read between the lines a little bit to notice the glaring gap in what I wrote. The one piece on the technical side of things that brought the whole house of cards down. The story concept was fine. It was the details in Teen Witch’s script that took the movie off the rails. In a good way, though. It was entertainingly bonkers.
This might start sounding like a fever dream. I’m telling you that now. I’m going to get into the specific moments of the movie that felt a little… off. There’s no real order to these bits. I’m going to start with Louise’s brother, who showed up immediately after Louise woke from the opening dance dream. Richie (Joshua Miller) was introduced to audiences while solo eating a giant chocolate cake under Louise’s bed. In a later scene, their parents were out, and he made a disaster of food in the kitchen. This character was all about food. Richie and Lousie argued in the disastrous kitchen before she turned him into a dog while he repeatedly called her a dog. That was followed by the weirdest voicework I’ve heard for a dog in a long time. The last Richie thing I want to mention is when he popped up to serve Louise, then brought her a school assignment that he ironed for her. Yes, he freshly ironed her homework. Weird kid, that Richie.
Next up, Louise’s dating stories. There are two of them that I want to make note of. The first came when she hadn’t yet found popularity and was only starting to realize her powers. She got paired up with an obnoxious nerd type for the high school dance. All he talked about was wanting to get up in her while his voice was somewhere between Shaggy from Scooby-Doo and Lewis from Revenge of the Nerds. After one too many advances, Louise told him to leave her alone and he straight up vanished from the car he was driving. Louise needed to quick think to make sure she didn’t die in the car.
The other bit of dating life wasn’t quite as magical. Louise brought Brad over to study. She was going to cast a love spell on him but chickened out. No magic was actually used. There was a little bit of manipulation, though. Louise wanted Brad to sit on the bed with her, so she hid all the chairs away in her closet. Everyone kept coming into her room to ask where the chairs were and she kept having to think of new excuses. It was another odd scene among all the odd scenes that made up Teen Witch.
You may be asking how Louise knew about the love spell that she wanted to cast on Brad. Well, she had a mentor. Zelda Rubinstein played Madame Serena Alcott, a witch who knew Louise from a previous life in Salem. She taught Louise how to harness her power, but also wanted to use Louise’s power for her own gain. Namely, she wanted to spruce up her house and turn her frog into a man she could bed down with. It’s not beastiality if the animal is a human now, right? In the end, Louise realized she didn’t want to be as superficial as her mentor and decided not to use her magic that way. She would be herself and not influence anyone.
Being herself led to strange things, though. Earlier in the movie, all the popular girls harassed her by doing a choreographed dance number to a song called “I Like Boys” in the locker room at school. It wasn’t a musical number because there was no singing. Just dancing. It felt like a music video had been inserted into the movie without any real thought. I wasn’t entirely sure why it was happening in that moment. I’m still not sure.
Louise’s teacher harassed her even more than her peers. He read her diary aloud to the class. He dug through her purse and showed everyone her belongings, including her birth control. The guy was a huge asshole. Until Louise humbled him, that is. She made a giant voodoo doll and used it to make him strip in front of the class. Yeah, there were some moments that felt ripped right out of an 80s sex comedy. The voodoo doll came up again when it fell down the stairs and the teacher then fell down a set of stairs. It made one more appearance when Louise’s mom threw it into the washer. The teacher followed suit by walking into a car wash. What a guy. What a punishment.
I almost forgot to mention the rap battle involving the song “Top That” and Louise’s best friend, Polly (Mandy Ingber). Louise didn’t only use her magic on herself. Polly had a crush on the leader of a three-white-man rap clique. These three guys would be standing in a corner anywhere, just rapping away. They rapped at Louise on her first day of school at the lockers. This scene had them rapping in the middle of the street, next to a parked car. Polly mentioned liking the guy. Louise used her spell to make Polly into a rap genius who went and duetted with the guy before getting on her bike and riding away. I don’t know if the two ever actually got together, but they had a memorable rap scene that anyone who has seen Teen Witch will talk about.
Teen Witch was filled with a whole bunch of insanity. The foundation of the story was a solid one. It was built as a coming-of-age story where the teenager had magical powers. The intentions were good. However, the road to Hell was paved with good intentions. There was a sex comedy style of writing that created a bunch of insane scenes and moments. It brought down the quality of the script. The technical side of Teen Witch wasn’t as good as initially thought. Everything was serviceable, but the script was bad. It was a bad movie, thanks to the writing.
I would still argue for the good-bad classification, though. The insanity may have brought down the quality of the script, but it made the overall movie much more entertaining and memorable. Based on the definition I gave off the top, that’s the correct category. The technical were good in moments and bad in moments. Nothing blew it out of the water. It was entertaining the whole way though. That’s some underwhelming technical and great entertainment. In the landscape of bad movies, it’s a peak. Not as high as Everest, but a peak all the same.
I’ve watched a lot of bad movies in my time, especially while writing this blog. I’ve come up with four categories that encapsulate 99.99% of the film landscape. I don’t know why I did this. I don’t know when I did this. All I know is that this is how my mind works, and this blog is my way to share my thoughts with you. The few people who actually read this. Thank you.
I’m going to leave you with some notes to finish things off here:
- Teen Witch featured Darcy DeMoss, who was previously featured in Sharknado 3: Oh Hell No! and Hardbodies.
- Not to be outdone, another three-timer was Jimmy Keegan, who was in Breakin’ 2: Electric Boogaloo, Over the Top, and Teen Witch.
- Then there was the other Jimmy. Jimmy Locust was in Teen Witch, Killer Klowns from Outer Space, and She’s Out of Control.
- Two other actors from She’s Out of Control were in Teen Witch. They were Megan Gallivan and Gary Schwartz.
- Teen Witch featured Tina Caspary from Mac and Me.
- Rita Wilson made a small appearance in Teen Witch. You might remember her for her larger role in Jingle All the Way.
- Dan Gauthier played Dan in Teen Witch. He also popped up in Son in Law.
- Teen Witch saw the return of Brett Baxter Clark to Sunday “Bad” Movies, following a first appearance in Malibu Express.
- Blood Diner and Teen Witch both featured Jared Chandler.
- Finally, Zelda Rubinstein was maybe the most recognizable actor in Teen Witch. She was also in Southland Tales.
- Have you seen Teen Witch? What did you think of it? Let me know your thoughts in the comments. If you don’t want to put them there, you can always find me on Threads or Bluesky as well.
- You can use the comments, Threads, or Bluesky to let me know what movies I should be checking out for Sunday “Bad” Movies. I’m always open to suggestions.
- The final thing to do is give you guys a heads up for what’s coming soon to a Sunday “Bad” Movies blog near you. I’ve got two movies lined up. The first one is a little movie called War of the Worlds. You know, the one from last month. The one that everyone already says is one of the worst movies ever. That one. After that, I’ve got a little movie called The Octagames. Clearly a play on Squid Game. Yeah, I’ll be getting into the horror with that one. We’re close enough to spooky season and I never know when these posts will be up, so that’ll be the start of horror for a bit here. Or Halloween-ish stuff. Who knows if it will all be horror? Anyway, see you next time for War of the Worlds.