I started writing Sunday “Bad” Movies posts in December 2012. That’s nearly thirteen years ago. Over that time, I’ve seen a myriad of bad movies, as well as some surprisingly good ones. I’ve watched one-offs and I’ve seen franchises. I’ve followed some actors through their bad movie careers, while there are some I still need to touch upon. It’s all in the name of learning about film in general.
One of the more enduring staples of Sunday “Bad” Movies has been the God’s Not Dead franchise. It took me a while to get into it. Over 200 posts, in fact. But once I was in, the franchise kept coming back. I was four and a half years into Sunday “Bad” Movies when I watched the first two. I watched each subsequent sequel as they were released. I guess you could say that’s my thing. I even ventured outside the franchise to check out Brother White, another religious movie featuring David A.R. White. Then I got around to what may have been his origin, Second Glance. There’s something about that man’s movie charisma that keeps pulling me back in.
The God’s Not Dead franchise are your stereotypical Christian propaganda movies. They don’t dive into historical Christian dramatizations. They aren’t that sort of story. God’s Not Dead and its four sequels are that type of Christian movie where people tell Christians they’re not allowed to believe in God. Yeah, this franchise is all about the persecution complex that flows through the entire Christian film genre. It might be the best at it, too. Sure, there are some missteps in each of the movies. Some things that might come down to ideologies being different. But they do a good job of coming up with interesting conflicts.
I’m honestly a little surprised that they managed to tell a different story within the confines of Christian persecution in each instalment. I’m even more surprised they managed to bring something interesting each time, too. I’m not going to outright say the movies are good. The persecution of Christians has never, in modern society, been as bad as the movies make it out to be. Or as miraculous.
God’s Not Dead began as a simple story that could have worked well outside the Christian audience if it were tweaked just slightly. And if all the surrounding “cancer cured by prayer” and “Christianity is better than Islam” stuff was removed. At its core, the first movie was about a philosophy professor telling his students that they could no longer believe in God, and the one student who refused to conform to this demand. Had the story positioned itself as a conflict about the freedom to believe, it would have been a perfect, captivating story. It didn’t do that.
God’s Not Dead saw the student guest lecturing for three classes in a debate with the professor. These lectures should have been about the aforementioned freedom of belief. Allow people to believe in whatever they chose. That would have been a universal theme that could have garnered a bigger audience. It wouldn’t be a Christian movie, though. The Christian filmmakers had to position themselves as the sole victim. The student argued about why God was real, essentially turning his trilogy of lectures into sermons to convert his classmates. The basis was there for a strong story about a teacher infringing upon people’s rights, but the Christian part of the Christian persecution complex brought it down.
God’s Not Dead 2 might have had the strongest conflict of the entire franchise. There were still some flaws as the inherently Christian story was pushed too far into the persecution side of things. A high school teacher was in court because of a classroom incident. A student who was exploring her religious beliefs asked the teacher about a comparison between a historical event and a Biblical event. The teacher answered the question with the relation between the events. Another student reported it and BOOM! A court case was opened because the teacher didn’t respect the boundaries within the separation of church and state.
The thing that held God’s Not Dead 2 back was how hard they hit the Christian persecution angle. The movie would have been fine as a court case involving the use of religion in a public school lesson, even though the teacher was just answering a question her student had. They took it a few steps further, though. The opposing lawyer had to declare he was using the case to “prove once and for all that God is dead.” He demanded they prove the Bible was historically accurate. They weren’t going after the teacher for her lesson as much as they were going after Christianity for existing.
Another storyline in God’s Not Dead 2 was that the government wanted Pastor Dave to turn over his sermons. He refused to share them, which led to his arrest at the conclusion of the film. I don’t know how accurate that is to reality, but it only helped to reinforce the persecution of Christians. It also led into the opening of the third God’s Not Dead movie.
God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness may not have had the strongest conflict, but it put an interesting spin on the Christian persecution stuff that permeated throughout the franchise. It made the third God’s Not Dead movie the most palatable. Pastor Dave was released from prison in time to see his campus church be vandalized. An angry student threw a brick through a window and started a fire. This coincided with the college’s decision to remove the church from campus grounds. Pastor Dave hired his lawyer brother to help him fight the school so he could keep the church.
There was a self-awareness to God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness that wasn’t present in the rest of the franchise. Yeah, it was still a movie about a pastor fighting against a college that wanted to remove Christianity from their campus. That Christian persecution complex was still there. The self-awareness made it feel different, though. It ended up not being a story about stopping belief. The lesson was about people having an equal opportunity to find faith, rather than have one faith pushed upon them. Pastor Dave was in the wrong for most of the movie. They never shied away from that fact. He even assaulted the vandal. He was not a heroic figure in this story, which made things more interesting. God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness was interesting because Pastor Dave learned that all faiths deserve to have followers, and his followers would come to Christianity no matter where his church was. It was humbling, in a way, to the Christian persecution complex that plagued the series.
Three movies. Three different ways that people tried to keep Christians from worshipping God. Or so the Christian audience would have you believe. Surely, the people behind the franchise would run into some repetition if they kept going. Not so fast. God’s Not Dead: We the People took the fight to congress. Pastor Dave led a bunch of church-sanctioned homeschooling. When a federal representative deemed their curriculum not up to governmental standards, he headed to Washington to fight the government in the capitol for their rights to homeschool their way.
If I remember correctly, a lot of the conflict was based on the whole science versus religion argument. Evolution and that sort of stuff. God’s Not Dead: We the People felt like the most fabricated conflict for the sake of Christian persecution. Each of these movies pulled from real stories, exaggerating them to pull on the persecution complex strings to their fullest extent. There are real stories of students being told they can’t be religious at school, or teachers getting in trouble for talking about religion. Colleges are moving away from having only one religion on campus due to inclusivity. These things are happening, though not to the extremes that these movies made them out to be. There has not, however, been a targeted governmental assault on religion in homeschooling. Between that wholly fabricated story and this instalment being kind of boring, it was time for a change.
That change would come in the form of God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust. The fifth film in the franchise would move away from the education thread that flowed through the first four movies, and dive fully into politics. Pastor Dave (David A.R. White) was enlisted to run in an election against Peter Kane (Ray Wise). Kane wanted to do all the right things. Tax churches, allow universal healthcare, make sure laws weren’t written in the name of God. But he went about it through mudslinging and manipulation. Pastor Dave, on the other hand, wanted to get elected to help his church, and he wouldn’t compromise his beliefs or his friendliness to do it. He thought honesty and openness was the best path. As much as his campaign manager wanted to tone down his religious side, it was a part of him. His honesty and openness required all of him. People would elect the real him, not a fabricated image of himself that hid key parts of who he was. And he wasn’t going to say anything bad about his opponent.
God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust changed things up in two major ways. First, it dropped the education thread that had been the backbone of every conflict in the series thus far. The other major change was that it didn’t attempt to play the story off as true. Sure, it somewhat satirized how broken the US political system is, and that things need to change. But it wasn’t some real story about how someone’s religious beliefs were being infringed upon. Outside of the bookend storyline about a church shelter that was being shut down. God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust mostly eschewed the Christian persecution complex and the education system for an election campaign storyline with a religious character. I guess, five movies in, the Christian persecution complex finally felt a little too tired to be the main focus of another movie.
The God’s Not Dead franchise has been going for over a decade. Five movies in eleven years. It is a franchise that has thrived off the Christian persecution complex. That hooked the audience the first time around. The Christian audience wanted to be the underdog fighting against the people putting them down. Somehow, the franchise kept finding new fights to be fought, mostly by the same pastor from the same Arkansas church. The fact that they’ve kept the franchise going as long as they have is a (new) testament to the Christian audiences’ appetites to watch movies where they can vicariously fight back against the anti-Christian forces that be. I’m curious how long it will be until they run out of causes for Pastor Dave to fight for.
I’ve been writing Sunday “Bad” Movies posts since 2012. There are only a few movies and franchises that have stuck with me then way God’s Not Dead has. It’s not that they’re great movies. There might only be two of them that I legitimately enjoy. And I don’t agree with the Christian persecution complex. Yet there’s something about them that has a grip on me. The conflicts have potential. David A.R. White has been a good presence as Pastor Dave. If they keep finding reasons to play victim, I’ll keep watching.
The last thing to do with this post is the notes:
- I mentioned God’s Not Dead, God’s Not Dead 2, God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness, and God’s Not Dead: We the People in this post. I also mentioned Brother White and Second Glance. They all featured David A.R. White, who made his seventh Sunday “Bad” Movies appearance in God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust.
- Vance Null was one of the directors on God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust. He also directed God’s Not Dead: We the People.
- I would like to take a moment to welcome Ray Wise into the Sunday “Bad” Movies five-timers’ club. His five movies were Big Ass Spider!, God’s Not Dead 2, Brother White, Atlas Shrugged: Part II, and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust.
- Dean Cain returned to Sunday “Bad” Movies in God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust. He was previously featured in A Nanny for Christmas, God’s Not Dead, and Futuresport.
- Duncan Phillips and Michael Tait have been in the same four movies. They were in God’s Not Dead, God’s Not Dead 2, God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness, and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust.
- Brad Heller showed up in God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness. He was also in God’s Not Dead 2 and Brother White.
- Scott Baio returned to Sunday “Bad” Movies with God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust. He had already been in Superbabies: Baby Geniuses 2 and Zapped!
- God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust featured Isaiah Washington following up his role in God’s Not Dead: We the People. He was also in Exit Wounds.
- God’s Not Dead: We the People and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust each featured Vincent De Paul, who was also in Sex and the City 2.
- God’s Not Dead, God’s Not Dead 2, and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust each featured Tommy Blaze, Jody Davis, and Jeff Frankenstein.
- Mike Huckabee was in God’s Not Dead 2 and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust.
- God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness and God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust each featured Segun Oduolowu.
- Finally, God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust had Kevin Downes return from God’s Not Dead: We the People.
- Have you seen God’s Not Dead: In God We Trust? Have you seen any of the movies? What are your thoughts on the franchise? You can share your thoughts in the comments, or find me on Bluesky or Threads.
- You can also drop any suggestions for movies to watch for future Sunday “Bad” Movies posts in the comments, on Bluesky, or on Threads.
- Let’s end things off with a little look to the future. I’ve got the next two movies picked out already. One was Teen Witch, which I had watched while finishing up the previous Sunday “Bad” Movies post. Another movie kind of fell in my lap. It’s a new movie that everyone has been talking about because of how accessible it is and how bad it is. Yeah, the brand-new War of the Worlds movie is coming up. I’ll see you soon for both of those.